The NFL reports a record-low concussion rate due to improved helmet technology, but players remain hesitant to adopt new gear. Learn more about the ongoing debate.
NFL Sees Drop in Concussions with Better Helmets, But Players Hesitate to Switch
The NFL credited a 17% drop in concussions this season to improved helmet technology and rule changes. The league also introduced Guardian Caps, a soft-shell helmet covering, in regular-season games after expanding their use in 2023 practices.
NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell highlighted the shift, saying, “One of the most significant changes this year was the adoption of the players wearing the best helmets. We had 370 players use the newest helmet designs, and I think that’s showing.”
Despite these advancements, convincing players to switch to the highest-rated helmets has been a challenge. Some athletes are reluctant to change their gear, especially since certain helmets that were previously approved moved to the “not recommended” category this season.
Also Read: New Orleans Gears Up for Super Bowl Party Despite Recent Tragedy
Players Resist Helmet Changes
Detroit Lions linebacker and NFL Players Association (NFLPA) President Jalen Reeves-Maybin acknowledged the difficulty in making the switch.
“We want to get everything data-driven, but there’s still an aspect of feel for a player who’s been playing this game for so long. Change is hard for some guys,” he said.
The NFL and the players union strengthened concussion protocols in 2022 after criticism over how the league handled Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa’s injury. He was stretchered off the field after a serious concussion, drawing national attention.
Tagovailoa suffered another concussion this season but declined to wear a Guardian Cap, calling it a “personal choice.” He instead uses a VICIS ZERO2 MATRIX ID QB helmet, which the league lists as “Guardian Cap optional.”
Also Read: Eagles’ Strong Bond Could Be Key to Super Bowl Victory
Concerns About Guardian Caps
Some players have complained about Guardian Caps, saying they affect balance and comfort. Washington Commanders running back Austin Ekeler shared his concerns, saying,
“The Guardian Cap feels heavy on my head. I love that it’s an option. You can use it if you like. I actually had two concussions this year, but I still feel like my equipment was sufficient.”
NFLPA Executive Director Lloyd Howell said he hopes the players union can take a bigger role in discussions on helmet safety.
Meanwhile, Philadelphia Eagles guard Tyler Steen expressed mixed feelings about helmet restrictions. While he admitted discomfort with the Guardian Cap, he said he would support it if it truly prevents injuries.
“If it’s definitely preventing more concussions and injuries, then yeah, for sure,” Steen told reporters before Sunday’s Super Bowl against the Kansas City Chiefs.
With player safety a growing concern, the debate over helmet technology is expected to continue as the league pushes for more adoption while players weigh performance and comfort.
Also Read: Patrick Mahomes: The Key to Kansas City’s Super Bowl Hopes